Manufacturing, Characterization and Use of Single Walled Carbon Nanotubes

Introduction to Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes

Single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs) are cylindrical tubes made by rolling a thin sheet of graphene into a single-walled hollow tube. SWCNTs, discovered in the early 1990s, are of peculiar physics and chemistry. They consist of carbon atoms held together in a hexagonal grid to make a tube that has a diameter between 1 and 2 nanometres and can be several tens of micrometres or longer.

Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes (SWCNTs)

High Purified SWCNTs, >95%

High Purified Short SWCNTs, >95%

High Purified Large Surface Area SWCNTs, >95%

SWCNTs, >90%

Short SWCNTs, >90%

SWCNTs, >60%

SWCNTs Dispersion

Structure of Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes (SWCNTs)

1. Graphene Lattice and Tubular Structure

SWCNTs are simply a sheet of graphene stretched over itself — a single atom layer of carbon atoms in a hexagonal structure. Every carbon atom in this lattice is attached to three neighbouring carbon atoms, with high-strength, stable covalent bonds. Roll into a cylindrical form The orientation, diameter and length of the graphene sheet determine the shape of the SWCNT.

2. Diameter and Length

Diameter: SWCNTs' diameter can vary from 0.7 to 2 nanometres, depending on the conditions and the way of synthesis. This diameter is much smaller than the diameter of multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs), which have multiple graphene layers.

Length: SWCNTs range from several nanometres to a few centimeters in length. It is not possible to precisely control the length at the synthesis stage, though long SWCNTs tend to be favoured for applications such as conductive films and fibres.

3. Chirality and Chiral Vector

The most obvious aspect of SWCNTs is chirality (aka "twist"), which is the orientation of the graphene sheet when it is bent into a tube. Chirality directly modulates electronic behavior of the SWCNT, which can be metallic or semiconducting. Chirality is defined as a pair of indices, (n,m) that are called the chiral vector and define the wrapping of the graphene sheet. This vector defines the arrangement of carbon atoms around the nanotube's circumference.

Armchair (n = m): When n=m, the SWCNT takes on an "armchair" shape, carbon atoms in an armchair-shaped arrangement. Armchair SWCNTs are metals with very good electrical conductivity.

Zigzag (m=0): With m=0 the SWCNT is "zigzag" which means that the carbon atoms go zigzag around the diameter of the tube. Zigzag SWCNTs are metallic or semiconducting based on n.

Chiral (n ≠ m, m ≠ 0): if neither n nor m is zero and n≠m then the SWCNT is "chiral". Chiral SWCNTs spiral around the tube and are semiconducting. These forms have unique electronic and optical structures useful for nanoelectronics and photonics.

4. Bonding and Electron Structure

The carbon atoms in SWCNTs are sp2-hybridized and bonded strongly to one another by covalent bonds. This sp² bonding contributes to the nanotube's strength and resilience. The electron structure depends on the chirality of the SWCNT:

Metal SWCNTs: Armchair SWCNTs (n = m) have delocalised electrons and hence are electrically very conductive.

Semiconducting SWCNTs: Zigzag and chiral SWCNTs can behave as semiconductors, where band gap varies with diameter and chirality. They are also used in field-effect transistors (FETs) and other electronic components because of this property.

5. Optical and Electronic Properties

SWCNTs' one-dimensional nature and chirality create special optical and electronic behaviour, such as quantised energy and unique absorption/emission wavelengths in the visible to near-infrared region. Such properties are critical in sensors, photodetectors, and optoelectronic equipment.

Because SWCNTs are governed by the diameter, length and chirality of the folded sheet of graphene, they are mechanically, electrically and optically different. It is for this versatility that SWCNTs are also an exciting material for next-generation applications in nanoelectronics to biomedicine.

Physical Parameters of SWCNTs vs MWCNTs

Physical Parameter	SWCNTs	MWCNTs
Number of Walls	Single layer of graphene rolled into a tube	Multiple concentric layers of graphene (2 or more)
Diameter	Typically 0.7–2 nm	Typically 2–100 nm
Length	Varies from a few nm to several cm	Varies from a few nm to several cm
Chirality	Defined by chiral vector (n, m), affecting properties	Each wall may have different chirality, reducing chirality control
Electrical Conductivity	Can be metallic or semiconducting depending on chirality	Primarily metallic due to overlapping electronic bands
Thermal Conductivity	Very high along the tube axis (≈3500 W/m·K)	Lower than SWCNTs due to inter-layer scattering
Tensile Strength	Extremely high (up to 100 times stronger than steel)	High, but typically lower than SWCNTs due to weak interlayer forces
Flexibility	Higher flexibility due to single-layer structure	Lower flexibility due to multiple layers and increased stiffness
Purity	Synthesis generally yields high purity	Synthesis can lead to structural defects and impurities
Density	Lower density due to single layer	Higher density because of multiple layers
Cost of Production	Higher due to more complex synthesis and purification	Lower due to simpler synthesis methods
Surface Area	Higher accessible surface area for a given mass	Lower accessible surface area due to inner walls
Applications	Nanoelectronics, sensors, drug delivery, composite materials	Composite materials, field emission devices, structural applications

Synthesis of SWCNTs

There are various synthesis methods of SWCNTs such as arc discharge, laser ablation, and chemical vapour deposition (CVD). These methods are all pros and cons, and are different applications suitable.

Arc Discharge Method: One of the earliest process for single-walled carbon nanotubes mass-produced in large scale. It's a process of creating an arc discharge in a low-pressure gas, with catalyst particles (Ni, Co, Fe, etc.) to promote nanotube growth. This method can achieve high yield and high purity SWCNTs, but growth rate and structural control are relatively challenging.

Laser Ablation Method: The laser beam is fired at a carbon target to evaporate the carbon and form carbon nanotubes. Laser ablation can yield SWCNTs with a narrow diameter distribution and more uniform shape, but the production yield is not large.

Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) Method: In today's times, this is one of the easiest and most economical synthesis techniques. In CVD process, CO₂ gasses (methane, ethylene, etc.) ).They are added to a reactor catalysts (Fe, Co, Ni, etc.) a lot of heat to create SWCNTs. This technique gives exact nanotube dimensions, length, and alignment and can be used in mass-produced products.

Parameter	Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD)	Laser Ablation	Arc Discharge
Process Description	Hydrocarbon gas decomposes on a catalyst surface, forming SWCNTs.	Laser vaporizes graphite with a metal catalyst target, creating a carbon vapor that condenses into SWCNTs.	High current arc between graphite electrodes creates a plasma, vaporizing carbon to form SWCNTs.
Temperature Range	Moderate (600–1200°C)	High (1200–1500°C)	Very high (>3000°C)
Growth Atmosphere	Often in an inert or reducing atmosphere (e.g., argon, hydrogen)	Inert gas (e.g., argon)	Inert gas (e.g., helium, argon)
Catalysts	Commonly Fe, Ni, Co, Mo	Ni, Co in the graphite target	Ni, Co in the graphite electrodes
Yield	High yield and scalability	Moderate to high yield, but limited scalability	Moderate yield with mixed types of CNTs
Quality of SWCNTs	High structural purity, with controllable diameter	High quality, fewer defects, uniform diameter	Moderate quality; mixed products (SWCNTs and MWCNTs)
Scalability	Highly scalable; suitable for large-scale production	Limited scalability due to complexity and cost	Limited scalability
Cost Efficiency	Relatively low cost, especially for large-scale production	High cost, especially for bulk production	Moderate cost, but not efficient for mass production
Diameter Control	Good diameter control through catalyst and temperature	Uniform diameter, but harder to control chirality	Limited control over diameter and chirality
Purity and Defects	Moderate to high purity; impurities depend on catalyst used	High purity, low defect density	Moderate purity; often requires post-synthesis purification
Advantages	- High yield - Good diameter control - Scalable	- High-quality, low-defect tubes - Uniform diameter	- Simple setup - Relatively low equipment cost
Disadvantages	- Catalyst particles often need to be removed - Somewhat lower quality than laser ablation	- High cost - Limited scalability	- Mixed CNT types - Lower quality and purity
Applications	Electronics, sensors, composite materials	High-performance electronics, optical devices	Field emission devices, structural applications

Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) is the most scalable and cost-effective method, suitable for industrial production, but it can require additional purification to remove catalyst particles.

Laser Ablation yields high-quality SWCNTs with fewer defects, ideal for high-performance applications, though it's limited in scalability and high in cost.

Arc Discharge is relatively simple and cost-effective but often produces a mixture of SWCNTs and MWCNTs with moderate quality, making it less suitable for applications requiring high purity.

The choice of synthesis method depends on the application needs, whether it's for high-quality, defect-free SWCNTs (Laser Ablation) or for scalable and economical production (CVD).

SWCNTs Characterization and Quality Assurance Parameters

Single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs) are very high-quality mechanical, thermal and electrical materials suitable for a wide range of applications. They must be characterised and quality checked to be functional and suitable. Here are the key characterization techniques and quality control standards of SWCNTs:

Characterization Methods

Characterization parameters	Characterization Techniques
Structural Characterization	Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM): TEM allows for the direct observation of the structure and morphology of SWCNTs including wall number, diameter distribution and length. Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): SEM provides surface information, and it can be used to study SWCNT dispersion, agglomeration, and surface properties. Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM): AFM can be used to measure the diameter and length of SWCNTs and is particularly useful when studying the thickness and surface morphology of thin film samples.
Diameter and Diameter Distribution	Raman Spectroscopy: Radial breathing mode (RBM) peak in Raman spectrum to calculate the size and distribution of SWCNTs. The ratio of the G to D peaks provides information on defect levels in the sample. UV-Visible-Near Infrared (UV-Vis-NIR) Spectroscopy: Estimates the diameter and electronic state of SWCNTs based on absorption peaks associated with the electronic band gap that help evaluate semiconductor and metallic SWCNT distribution.
Purity and Impurity Analysis	Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA): TGA measures sample thermal stability and carbon percentage, gives measurable information on impurities such as metal catalyst residues and carbon impurities. X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS): XPS measures surface elemental structure, for metal impurities and oxidation states of SWCNTs. Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS): ICP-MS measures the metal content of samples with accuracy (such as to look for residual catalysts).
Crystalline Structure and Defect Levels	X-ray Diffraction (XRD): XRD measurements the crystallization state and graphitisation of SWCNTs to verify crystallization and alignment. D/G Peak Ratio in Raman Spectroscopy: The D peak is defects, and the G peak is the degree of graphitization. Low D/G ratio means less defects and this translates into high-quality SWCNTs.
Electrical and Thermal Properties	Resistivity Measurement: Conductivity measurement determines metallic or semiconductive SWCNTs suitability for electronics. Thermal Conductivity Measurement: Thermal conductivity is measured to evaluate the heat transfer capacity of SWCNTs, which is very important in the case of thermal management.
Dispersion and Processability	Zeta Potential: Zeta potential gives information about SWCNT stability and dispersion in solution, to identify their dispersion capabilities in different media. Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS): DLS looks at particle size distribution in solution and gives a snapshot of SWCNT dispersion state.
Chemical Properties and Functionalization	Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR): FTIR measures surface chemical functional groups and determines whether chemical modifications or functionalisations occurred to SWCNTs. XPS and Raman Spectroscopy: XPS maps surface oxidation states and Raman spectroscopy detects the presence of functional groups.

Quality Assurance Parameters

The quality assurance of SWCNTs relies on rigorous characterization and testing processes. Through precise analysis of structure, size, purity, and electrical/thermal properties, SWCNTs can be provided to users at the high quality required for various applications.

Applications of Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes (SWCNTs)

SWCNTs have high mechanical, thermal and electrical properties and thus can be applied to many areas. Following are the main use cases for SWCNTs:

1. Electronics and Semiconductor Devices

Transistors and Field-Effect Transistors (FETs): With high conductivity and semiconductor characteristics, SWCNTs are used in nano-scale transistors and FETs. They carry high carrier mobility and consume low power, and could be used in next-generation microelectronics.

Conductive Films and Transparent Conductive Electrodes: SWCNTs are applications as transparent conductive electrodes in touch screens, liquid crystal displays (LCDs), and organic optoelectronics. They are conductive and transparent films that are more malleable than classic indium tin oxide (ITO).

Sensors: SWCNTs are highly reactive towards gas molecules (NO₂, NH₃, CO) and low concentration, so ideal for high-sensitivity chemical gas sensors. Also, SWCNTs' conductivity also shifts with the environment (temperature and humidity), so they can be used in temperature and humidity sensors.

2. Reinforcements in Composite Materials

Polymer Composites: SWCNTs can add mechanical strength, conductivity and thermal conductivity to polymer matrix in many applications. The usual uses are lightweight, high-tensile materials for the aerospace and automotive sectors, conductive coatings, and anti-static coatings.

Metal Matrix Composites: SWCNTs combined with metals enhance strength and hardness of metallic material without heavy weight, ideal for super strong, ultra-lightweight structural systems.

Ceramic Matrix Composites: SWCNTs in ceramics can make ceramic materials stronger and crack-resistant, especially when used in heat and wear resistance applications.

3. Energy Storage and Conversion

Lithium-Ion Batteries: SWCNTs can be used as conductive additives and electrode materials for lithium-ion batteries to increase electrode conductivity, surface area and charge retention leading to improved energy density and cycle life.

Supercapacitors: Because of the surface area and conductivity, SWCNTs are the ideal material for high-efficiency supercapacitors that can store more energy and discharge faster.

Fuel Cells: SWCNTs can act as catalyst supports for the fuel cell to make it more active and durable. They're also very conductive, which helps to carry the charge and thereby increase the efficiency of fuel cells.

4. Biomedicine

Drug Delivery: SWCNTs have the same sized shape as cells, and they can be tuned for biocompatibility making them suitable as targeted drug delivery systems. Through chemical modification, SWCNTs can carry drugs molecules to the cancer cells or other particular cells, which provide more effective therapy and less adverse effects.

Biosensors: SWCNTs can also identify the bind-specificity of biomolecules like DNA, RNA, and proteins for ultrasensitive biosensors. They promise biomedical surveillance and disease early-onset.

Bioimaging: Integrated SWCNTs are applicable for bioimaging and photothermal therapy with good performance for cancer diagnosis and treatment. For instance, SWCNTs fluoresce in the near-infrared for in vivo imaging, and kill cancer cells by photothermal means.

5. Optoelectronics and Optical Devices

Photodetectors and Solar Cells: SWCNTs can be active materials for photodetectors, which detect the photons and convert them into electrical current. They are also efficient light-absorbing elements in solar cells to optimize photoelectric conversion.

LEDs and Laser Devices: SWCNTs' good optoelectronics can be applied to create light-emitting diodes (LEDs) and nano-lasers used for high-end displays and optical communications.

6. Environmental Protection and Remediation

Water Treatment and Adsorption of Pollutants: Due to the high surface area and adsorption, SWCNTs are ideal for organic contaminants, heavy metal ions etc. from water. Operated SWCNTs can selectively pick up specific pollutants and could be used to purify the environment.

Air Cleaners & Exhaust Treatment: SWCNTs are applicable to fabricate filters that capture harmful airborne particles or gases. Also, they are very catalytic for exhaust gas filtration.

Because of their peculiar physical, chemical and mechanical nature, single-walled carbon nanotubes have widespread applications in electronics, energy, biomedicine, environmental protection and material science. While the practical applications for large-scale use are still in progress, preparation, functionalization and separation technology will continue to increase the potential of SWCNTs as new solutions to industries emerge.

Challenges of Single Walled Carbon Nanotubes (SWNTs)

SWCNTs are remarkable, but their commercial and scientific prospects have been constrained by a number of serious barriers. These difficulties stem from problems in synthesis, processing, and application that impair their utility and scalability. The main problems are as follows:

1. Synthesis and Cost

Precise Control of Chirality: SWCNTs electronic properties (metallic or semiconducting) depend on chirality. However, achieving chirality-specific synthesis is highly challenging and often yields a mixture of types, making it difficult to separate metallic from semiconducting tubes. This limits their application in electronics, where specific electronic properties are essential.

Scalability and Price Competitiveness: The processes for the manufacture of quality SWCNTs, including Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) and Laser Ablation are very costly and difficult to mass-produce. Hence the price of mass production of high purity SWCNT for most industries is still too expensive.

2. Purity and Quality Control

Impurities and Structural Defects: SWCNTs may have lingering catalyst granules, carbony impurities, or synthesis defects. These impurities degrade electrical and mechanical properties, necessitating further purification processes, which make production more expensive and difficult.

Defect Control: In SWCNTs, defects impact mechanical strength, electrical conductivity and chemical sensitivity. There are some defects that can be beneficial in some applications, but the majority of defects make the application slow, especially for electronics.

3. Dispersion and Aggregation

Poor Solubility: SWCNTs tend to aggregate due to strong van der Waals forces, which make them difficult to disperse uniformly in solvents and composite matrices. This aggregation affects their mechanical and conductive properties and limits their integration into polymers, resins, and other composite materials.

Functionalization and Stability: Chemical functionalization can improve SWCNTs' dispersibility in various solvents, but functionalization may alter or degrade their intrinsic properties, such as conductivity. Striking a balance between improved dispersion and property retention is a persistent challenge.

4. Handling and Safety Concerns

Health and Environmental Hazards: The health hazards of exposing people to SWCNTs (for example, inhalation asthma) are still being investigated. The toxicity and long-term environmental effects are a concern, and it is difficult to handle and to get them for general consumption.

Safe Manufacturing and Disposal: SWCNTs must be manufactured according to strict environmental and safety regulations that increase the cost of protection equipment, waste collection and disposal.

5. Characterization and Standardization

Characterization Challenges: Defining SWCNTs in details with regard to chirality, purity, defect density, etc., is a difficult task and frequently demands advanced methods such as Raman spectroscopy, TEM, and SEM. These methods are expensive, time consuming, and rarely practical for mass production monitoring.

Standards are Inadequate: No one standardized the characterisation, grade and quality control of SWCNTs among vendors and laboratories. This disparity makes comparisons difficult and makes it hard to know if SWCNTs are good and useful for certain applications.

6. Integration into Devices and Systems

Device Fabrication and Alignment: SWCNTs' integration into electronic and photonic devices requires precise alignment and placement. The issue of aligning uniformly at scale discourages their use in transistors, sensors and other nanomachines.

Compatible with Current Manufacturing Methods: SWCNTs need to be compatible with current manufacturing methods, such as in electronics, energy, and aerospace. Adapting SWCNTs to existing production systems (at scale), however, is still challenging with handling issues and inconsistent material behavior.

7. Performance Consistency

Reproducibility and Reliability: Synthesis and processing can vary, which results in variations in SWCNTs' performances, which is not an ideal solution for applications that demand reproducible performance. Disparity in diameter, length and chirality will result in electrical, mechanical and thermal properties which can differ from batch to batch.

Stability over the Long Run: SWCNTs may degrade over time or under specific environmental conditions (e.g., exposure to air, moisture, high temperature). Stability and longevity, especially for use in vital electronics or biomedicine, are crucial to performance.

References

1. Zamzami, M. A., et al. "Carbon nanotube field-effect transistor (CNT-FET)-based biosensor for rapid detection of SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19) surface spike protein S1." Bioelectrochemistry 143 (2022): 107982.
2. Arora, Neha, and N. N. Sharma. "Arc discharge synthesis of carbon nanotubes: Comprehensive review." Diamond and related materials 50 (2014): 135-150.
3. Venkataraman, A., et al. "Carbon nanotube assembly and integration for applications." Nanoscale research letters 14 (2019): 1-47.
4. Mubarak, N. M., et al. "The production of carbon nanotubes using two-stage chemical vapor deposition and their potential use in protein purification." Chemical engineering journal 168.1 (2011): 461-469.
5. Yoon, B., et al. "Switchable single-walled carbon nanotube–polymer composites for CO2 sensing." ACS applied materials & interfaces 10.39 (2018): 33373-33379.
6. Bento, F. R., et al. "Inexpensive methodology for obtaining flexible SnO 2-single-walled carbon nanotube composites for lithium-ion battery anodes." Journal of Solid State Electrochemistry 23 (2019): 1861-1870.
7. Karchemski, F., et al. "Carbon nanotubes-liposomes conjugate as a platform for drug delivery into cells." Journal of controlled release 160.2 (2012): 339-345.
8. Chen, C., et al. "High-performance infrared photodetector based on single-wall carbon nanotube films." Carbon 206 (2023): 150-156.
9. Chowdhury, Z. Z., et al. "Electrochemically active carbon nanotube (CNT) membrane filter for desalination and water purification." Emerging Technologies for Sustainable Desalination Handbook. Butterworth-Heinemann, 2018. 333-363.